Q1. Discuss Maurice Dobb's and Guy Bois's views on the debate ontransition from feudalism to capitalism.
- Dobb: Feudalism declined due to internal contradictions and lordly overexploitation of peasants.
- Dobb: Peasant resistance, flight, and commutation of labor services into money rents weakened feudal control.
- Dobb: Trade was secondary, dissolving feudalism but not its primary cause; petty commodity production rose internally.
- Bois: Transition driven by a 'systemic crisis' of feudalism in the 14th century, not just exploitation.
Answer: The debate on the transition from feudalism to capitalism is a cornerstone of historical materialism, largely shaped by Marxist historians. Maurice Dobb initiated a powerful argument emphasizing internal contradictions within feudalism, while Guy Bois later provided a more refined structural analysis of its systemic crisis, both challenging explanations centered solely on external trade. Maurice Dobb, in his seminal work *Studies in the Development of Capitalism*, contended that the primary imp...